Knotty Geeks Episode 38 - Sad Puppies

Posted by: Jeremy Reimer on Mon Sep 14 09:56:27 2015.

In this episode, we talk about the fallout from the recent Hugo Awards, and the ramifications of the Sad and Rabid Puppy campaigns. We also review one of the recent Hugo winners, the excellent novel "The Three Body Problem."

Direct link to podcast

Notes from the show:

The Three Body Problem:

Views: 2781


By xradionut on Fri Oct 23 10:45:37 2015

Well, you got most of the background correct.

The main issues that pissed off the Sad Puppy crowd, is that the insular group of voters had gone PC and SJW, so that works of low quality, but were PC/SJW got nominated or the authors/editors that were politically connected won. Examples, "Red Shirts", "If You were a Dinosaur, My Love" or the blahness that is "Ancillary Justice". Also one of awards, "Long Format Editor", was created just so a few buddies could get awards. Plus the mock awards that were the "Assterix" handed out to the losers and some very deserving editors that were absolutely shit on by No Award.

Toss in a bit of cultural warfare, some GamerGate and a shit ton of grudges plus the conflict between the publishing houses and the independents, and add gasoline.

I know authors on all sides and neutral. I’ve had long conversations at cons and online with many of them. There’s trolls on all sides. There’s some crappy people on all sides. There’s a nugget of truth to the Sad Puppies message that got lost in the shit slinging.

Overall the Hugo and WorldCon doesn’t represent science fiction nor literary science fiction anymore. So much has changed in the last two decades. SciFi is more mainstream and the bulk of WorldCon voters is the same folks that have been around since the ’70s, add in a twist of open lesbians, gays and pedophiles* that have come out of the closet opposed by some religious, more conservative writers.

(*Bradley and Delany)

Except for a few volumes a month, I’ve pretty much retired from sci-fi reading. After 40 years of reading the genre, I’ve pretty much mined it out. That time is replaced with other hobbies and pass times that are more reality based.

By Jeremy Reimer on Wed Oct 28 14:53:34 2015

There’s a nugget of truth to the Sad Puppies message that got lost in the shit slinging.

I think you’re right, but the fact that the Sad (and then much more with the Rabid) Puppies chose to make their point via trying to disrupt the awards process basically made it impossible to make their point properly. They raised their own shit-storm, and thus lost the right to complain that their message was lost.

I think it’s true that the Sci-Fi fan community has become a bit insular (and a lot of long-time readers aren’t reading it as much any more, like your own example shows) and that’s troubling for sci-fi fans like myself. But what the Sad Puppies did wasn’t the right way to bring these concerns to light.

By xradionut on Fri Oct 30 10:06:11 2015

Right now and the near future, I’m pretty much ignoring literary Sci-Fi. I don’t want to have to research authors to see whom deserves my money and time.

For pure recreational escapism, I’ll be PC/console gaming with the wife. Much of my reading time is switched to radio and electronics along with a good chuck of OSS programming. I still have to keep a foot in the Windows world due to work, but I’m dedicating some time to Linux and Rust programming*. Maybe get an OberonStation...

*(Cultural wars split the local Python group. I can’t make this shit up,but it’s stupid sad. Also the local SQL Server group...)

By AllYorBaseRBelong2Us on Wed May 3 16:28:26 2017

AYB is smamming this thread.

Acting like an adult still does wonders for getting others to consider one’s message. It doesn’t guarantee it, but it may attract the attention of the few serious thinkers that still exist these days.....

By Jeremy Reimer on Thu May 11 10:59:20 2017

As always, AYB is in with the wisdom!